Why The AI Oligarchs Lost Big In The Midterms
November 05, 202601:20:40

Why The AI Oligarchs Lost Big In The Midterms

This week Jason Howell and Jeff Jarvis dig into an election where AI data centers became a deciding issue, as Democrats flipped Congress and new governors in Texas, Ohio and Georgia promised to slow the buildout. Jeff argues the real target is AI's oligarchs, OpenAI rebrands data centers as "AI compute campuses," and Anthropic's revised S-1 shows $17 billion in quarterly revenue, nearly $900 billion in commitments and a warning that self-building AI may be imminent.

Also in this episode: Google tells schools that no AI means no Search, AI users work longer days, Gartner bets on open models, and the security firm behind the AI breakouts blames its own error. New episodes every Wednesday at aiinside.show.

Note: Time codes subject to change depending on dynamic ad insertion by the distributor.

CHAPTERS:

00:00 - Podcast begins

06:37 - Midterms, data centers and AI oligarchs

26:07 - Anthropic IPO, revenue and computing commitments

30:57 - Self-building AI and model welfare

36:24 - Google Search and AI in schools

46:50 - Are AI users working longer days?

53:37 - Open models and enterprise agents

58:39 - Jensen Huang spy-plot reporting

1:02:31 - AI security tests and independent oversight

1:06:15 - ChatGPT Chat and Work tabs

1:07:20 - Apple Watch Live Rewind

1:11:22 - Apple age limits for AI companions

1:12:01 - Claude Code and game cloning

1:13:30 - Closing thoughts and plugs

Hosts: Jason Howell and Jeff Jarvis

Download and subscribe to AI Inside in audio and video: https://aiinside.show/

Support the podcast on Patreon for special perks: https://www.patreon.com/aiinsideshow. You’ll get ad-free audio and video feeds, a members-only Discord, T-shirts and stickers, and exclusive content.

Jason Howell
00:00
Coming up next, artificial intelligence was on the ballot last night here in the U. S. for the midterm elections. And what is the result? Well, data centers lost Big time.

00:09
Also, Anthropic's updated IPO filing says self-building AI may actually be imminent. Google tells schools You can turn off our AI, you'll just lose search too for your students, and so much more coming up on this next episode of the AI Inside Podcast. What's going on, everybody?

00:42
Welcome to another episode. of AI Inside the Show. We take a look at the AI that is layered throughout the world of technology.

00:49
I am one of your hosts, Jason Howell, joined from the other side of the country. uh by Jeff Jarvis. Good to see you, Jeff.

Jeff Jarvis
00:56
Good to see you, boss. How are you?

Jason Howell
00:58
I'm uh I'm doing good, you know, I'm feeling good. It's a little cold in this house because things are cooling. Probably not as cool as as Things are where you're at that.

Jeff Jarvis
01:08
Seventy-four degrees today.

Jason Howell
01:09
Are you kidding me? Oh wow.

Jeff Jarvis
01:11
November. It's quite lovely. Uh our heat died briefly uh two days ago, but it's supposed to be back working, not wood. So yeah, no, I'm out of a lovely walk. I've even I've been s More than you want to know. I even sweated on

Jason Howell
01:23
I I I know what you're talking about where you go outside and you don't expect it and then at the end of it you're like, wow, okay, yeah, it is different. Like maybe the air is a little heavier too, but you know, sometimes it's like humidity and Whatever. But yeah, it's a little cooler outside here today or has been.

01:38
Um but yeah. Good. Well I'm happy you had a pleasant walk.

Jeff Jarvis
01:42
Yeah, I'm I'm tired as hell because I stayed up till one o'clock in the morning, uh podcasting with the election With my friends uh Julia Roginski and Michelle Kitty. Uh the May Day Network.

Jason Howell
01:52
So what is the podcast that 's a good idea?

Jeff Jarvis
01:59
Uh they're both political operatives and so we talk about media, but then last night they were gonna be on from 7 p. m. on and I got I thought I'd visit for a little while and uh finally at one o'clock we all AM we all finally said okay we're tired now doesn't we

Jason Howell
02:10
're gonna One o'clock East Coast time.

Jeff Jarvis
02:13
Yeah, it's all a little zonked.

Jason Howell
02:15
Yeah, that was about the time that I headed to bed on the west west coast. So I'm a little bit of a uh a wimp um in regards to that. But yeah, last night, big uh big moment here in the US. And I would say, you know, worldwide there's been a lot of uh reaction From all over. I posted uh things have changed.

Jeff Jarvis
02:35
Not quite right, but I I I go to the German papers and um

Jason Howell
02:40
Oh, I think I saw this on threads, right?

Jeff Jarvis
02:43
Uh which I uh it's a paper I love. They're they're just brilliant. They had one where they said um with it with a picture of Trump glowering in a darkened room with just a little light on his face and says, Schluss mit Daddy. Enough with daddy.

Jason Howell
02:58
Enough with daddy. Oh, I think I think.

Jeff Jarvis
03:00
That was their lead story.

Jason Howell
03:03
Bloop.

Jeff Jarvis
03:03
And then their spiegel uh had another one which I'm not gonna find right now, but it it basically said this is the new face of the oh here it is. Um this is America's new guard. They talked about this is the new face of democracy in America now.

Jason Howell
03:19
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
03:20
So yeah, the world I was fascinated last night I was looking at these, and they're covering our election as if it's their election because it affects their lives.

Jason Howell
03:28
Absolutely. Yes. I I really noticed that too.

03:31
Like as I was going to bed last night, or right before I was going to bed, I was kind of checking some of the socials. Um, you know, we were podcasting doing Android Faithful, and actually you and I were just talking right before we opened the stream. Android the Android show that I have done since 2010 has always been a Tuesday night show.

03:47
And so every election night, me and the the cast, Ron Richards and Florence and Wynne and whatever, we're always podcasting during this really monumental moment. And it's like, God, do I even dare open a browser? Because I'm in the middle of this thing and I don't want to distract myself and either be elated or disappointed or whatever and everything.

04:08
And so I didn't I I forced Like, uh not forcefully, but purposefully didn't pay attention until I knew I had time to pay attention. And um and so when I was going to bed last night, I I logged into like threads, I think, and noticed that like On the other side of the world, people were waking up and seeing what what we knew at that point. And just yeah, it was it was really interesting because There it did seem exactly like you say, like they're as invested as we are as US you know citizens um in the consequences of not just an election, a US election, but a midterm election.

04:46
I think one of the comments I saw is like couple of years ago I couldn't even tell you what a midterm election actually was, but this year I was tuned in. I couldn't peel myself away from it. You know what I mean?

04:56
So

Jeff Jarvis
04:56
very

Jason Howell
04:57
much

Jeff Jarvis
04:58
great to get different perspectives on this. uh the day before the election declared identity politics dead. And the um uh the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, which is a conservative paper in Germany, uh the day after the election said that this was uh a case of diversity winning.

05:16
And so you see a different perspective. And let's just let's just pause for one quick moment at the wonder of the internet. We can see these perspectives now as they occur all around the world.

05:27
We can we can get them translated Um and it just opens up our perspectives. All you have to do is go looking for them. It's really quite a wonderful, amazing thing.

Jason Howell
05:35
It is. And you get those perspectives immediately. Yeah, I mean, you know, the internet is an incredible.

05:42
technology. Yes. There are probably also people that look at it and be like, yeah, but the internet has like the internet promised to unite people through Through this immediacy of shared knowledge, but it's actually divided people because of all these other unintended consequences.

05:59
And probably a little bit of this and a little bit of a lot of it.

Jeff Jarvis
06:01
As I am fond of pointing out Gutenberg may have printed a Bible, but they also quickly printed uh Balius Maleficarum, which was the manual for hunting and killing witches. The technology is used in multiple ways.

Jason Howell
06:16
I haven't heard that one before. Wow. Okay. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.

Jeff Jarvis
06:20
It led to the scientific revolution. It also led to the increase of the spreading of alchemy and and disinformation So, you know, yeah, same ever with us. It's about us. It's not about the technology. It's about us, us corrupt humans.

Jason Howell
06:34
Yeah, that's true. Right. At the end of the day.

06:37
Um well, yeah. So and and you know I would say that this podcast we don't normally talk a lot about like politics um from like a taking sides perspective or anything like that. We recognize that everybody who watches and listens has their own, you know, their own background and their own beliefs and and all that.

06:56
I do think that it is important though to spend some time talking about the election, and I think you would agree, because there are immediate and direct impacts on this show all the time. um brewing around support for you know the leaders of these AI companies, the competitiveness of the US uh to other countries like China when it comes to AI and the need to be a superpower and artificial intelligence or I'm sorry, uh what is it, superintelligence. Let's not car call it artificial anymore.

Jeff Jarvis
07:31
I think we're now allowed to call it artificial. I think I think that 's reverse.

Jason Howell
07:39
Um but how how this all really directly relates, as we'll talk about, is that a a big um a a big kind of wedge uh what is it called? A wedge position? Wedge issue has been the development of data centers and uh data centers and the the necessity of data center build-outs for this rapid proliferation development of artificial intelligence to keep the United States.

08:07
competitive and leading in AI, blah de blah de blah. Well now this has been uh definitely an issue that a lot of the people who won their election and actually won in the face of Republican opponents were pushing against the development of data center or at least to slowing it down to putting pauses in place to take a more, let's say, measured approach as opposed to the who cares, let's just go full steam ahead and see what happens. And um so a lot of people are interpreting this as a moment where AI, you know, the the the the big AI companies uh might and likely will be forced to kind of make some changes to how they operate in the coming couple of years.

08:50
Would you say that's pretty fair?

Jeff Jarvis
08:52
Yeah. I'm gonna crib here from Padre who's hosting um uh intelligent machines later today uh from the

Jason Howell
09:01
oh awesome

Jeff Jarvis
09:02
yeah she's great love love padre so he put in his notes some of a cadge from him if he doesn't mind from ballotopedia There were 50 ballot measures in 13 states that dealt with banning, approving, or advising DC projects, data center projects Um and so a lot of of legislation was there. As you mentioned, the politicians who won, the governors who won won in part on this. But I was on the podcast last night about the election.

09:27
uh a really smart pollster named Ben um said that one of the key things was they stuck to the messaging about data centers, data centers, data centers. And it was a way to uh garner uh support. So I think the data centers are borked.

09:44
The state also the states where they were going to be heaviest is places like Texas.

Jason Howell
09:49
Texas, right? Which I mean a b monumental, which is probably to say the least. Monumental turn Uh in Texas going uh Democratic um largely away from Republican.

Jeff Jarvis
10:04
Every statewide office uh legislature is the right thing.

Jason Howell
10:06
Couldn't have guessed that that would happen.

Jeff Jarvis
10:08
So um uh You know, there there are red states where we'll welcome data centers, I suspect. But the even there, they're unpopular with the right as well. So that's gonna be issues.

10:19
So so that's I think data centers are worked right now. And and uh we talked about this the other week. I think they're gonna hide in other forms.

10:27
I think I think, you know, the the Lord and Taylor near me may have some big crates moved in from NVIDIA. Yes, the

Jason Howell
10:33
whole uh let's bring data centers into the shopping mall strategy that we talked about weeks ago, which I still

Jeff Jarvis
10:42
talk about naming in a few minutes. But the other thing, Jason, is I my concern is and I said this to the pollster uh last night, I I I keep saying the data centers are the MacGuffin. They're the they're the device that people look at because it's the it's something tangible they can point to.

10:58
Uh the uh the arg the i and fine, data centers are are because there isn't enough electricity, they're running horrible noxish fumes with jets. and jet engines and turbines. Um uh they have some effect on water.

11:11
We're not exactly sure what at this point depends on how they're built. Uh they're ugly. Uh they don't have long term employment.

11:18
Right? So all that is true. All that I stipulate, Your Honor.

11:21
But I don't think the issue is really data centers. I think the issue is oligarchs. The issue is the AI boys who have too much power, too much wealth, we thought too much sway.

11:34
Though

Jason Howell
11:35
Which is impressive because they were loading a lot of money into this this election too, right? Like they were still had a

Jeff Jarvis
11:41
Elon Musk

Jason Howell
11:43
and stuff

Jeff Jarvis
11:43
had a huge uh uh defeat. However, in California, I'm jumping around our rundown now.

Jason Howell
11:48
No, it's fine. Uh-huh.

Jeff Jarvis
11:55
Though it was a really, I think, badly written law.

Jason Howell
11:58
That was my interpretation of it too, is that the

Jeff Jarvis
12:02
problem is you can see it expanding that if that sets a precedent and you're a farmer and and you've had a bad year and now you've got to give up N percent of your farm's value to a tax when you don't have any income this year. But that's the fear people have. We have to figure out how to redistribute the wealth that occurs at that high level.

12:19
People resent these oligarchs. They resent the, again, the power and the concentration of wealth. and and the the uh lack of equity, uh number one.

12:29
And number two, I would argue that we've got to focus attention on the nutballs who are nutty And the cultists and and the problems that exist there. And our media cover these guys as if they're just another uh good entrepreneur, when in my mind they're not, as I keep saying lately, the wrong people are in control of AI. So the question becomes, can can the can the discussion about AI get more uh focused on outcomes?

12:57
If you kill a data center in your state, fine, great. That ain't gonna kill AI. That doesn't kill their power.

13:03
They're gonna put 'em under the ocean. They're gonna put 'em in space for God's sakes. Google has its first center up there operating, writing haiku Literally.

Jason Howell
13:10
Elon Musk is already saying data centers in space looking pretty appealing right now. Of course he's got SpaceX and a whole lot of incentive to do something like that.

Jeff Jarvis
13:19
So I think it would be a mistake to concentrate on on the data centers, and if the politicians stop there, they're going to find themselves surprised by the left flank. Coming in where but they're still threatening they can kill us all. They're still taking all our money and they're still um you know, doing nasty things with people

Jason Howell
13:42
No, no, you've mentioned that and I it's on my list.

Jeff Jarvis
13:44
So I watched before before the I wanted to watch before the today Um and I won't go into any great detail about it, but uh it's from the creators of The Good Wife and The Good Fight, who I like a lot. And it's it's it's interesting. It's good.

13:58
It's two lawyers who get ousted from their Silicon Valley firm. They create a new law firm. and and it sets up continuing storylines.

14:05
And it hasn't hit data centers yet, but it's it's demonizing, it's making negative these tech companies and their moguls They're the bad guys. Not cartoonish, really, but just bad guys. And so I think the the culture is speaking.

14:20
The politics are speaking. The culture is speaking. The media aren't yet speaking because they don't really understand the full depth of what these guys are like But to me, that's the election issue we've got to move forward on.

14:31
So I know I have a new representative in my district. Yay, I fought for her. uh Rebecca Bennett and she's saying the things about data centers.

14:40
And I've got a I want to try to get to her office and say, let's have a conversation about something else here. And it's bigger. So meanwhile

Jason Howell
14:47
So kind of like the the data center is the stepping stone to the real problem, which is you go one step higher and it's not a good thing. If you stop there, it's a mistake.

Jeff Jarvis
14:54
So data centers are are screwed, number one Number two, we'll stay on this for one more second, which is OpenAI's hilarity. That they've solved, they're going to solve the problem. What are they going to do, Jason?

Jason Howell
15:07
Marketing. They're gonna change it so that we don't talk about you know, just as as the Trump administration said we can no longer say artificial intelligence for it is now superintelligence. OpenAI says, well we're not building data centers, we're building AI compute campuses.

Jeff Jarvis
15:23
A campus. Doesn't that sound nice? Let's go meet the student union and get ourselves a little data on the latte.

Jason Howell
15:31
It needs a yes, these data centers it's not a it's not a problem, the data centers inherently. It's it's a marketing issue. It's a quad.

15:38
Yes. Meanwhile they've been data centers for so so long, why suddenly they are an issue is just yeah. Yeah.

15:46
That requires a new marketing term. I don't know. But that's the thing.

Jeff Jarvis
15:49
And I come back to the issue of the uh turbines, the gas turbines. Uh Google leading the way for years has said they were going to go uh uh uh energy neutral. And uh we're celebrating the the time when uh energy became renewable energy became cheaper than coal, which were there But because there isn't enough supply of energy, of course, they're putting in turbines.

16:12
One story I put up this week uh from the Times is that um old jet engines surplus uh or or old jets engines surplus engines are being pulled to make turbines For um data centers. They're noisy, they're polluting, they're awful. This is not the way to win friends and influence politics.

16:36
So this is the data center thing again. All right, so that's data centers is one. um focus I think post-election.

16:44
The next, which we've already touched on, is taxing the billionaires. I think that the the the um Backlash against technology is a backlash against oligarchs.

Jason Howell
16:59
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
16:59
Both the companies and the investors, the Peter like people, people like Peter Thiel and all that. So I think we're going to see now efforts to find ways to tax them and nobody's going to stand up for them.

Jason Howell
17:10
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
17:11
Uh and Gavin Newson can't protect you from federal taxes. And uh for the next two years you may not get uh it passed, but you know, you can't pass a budget at all without the House. So I think we're gonna see uh efforts to tax these people and these companies.

Jason Howell
17:27
Two.

Jeff Jarvis
17:27
Three is regulation of AI, which will come from four investigation of AI. So we're going to see a ton of hearings on Capitol Hill. about AI, about these companies, pulling them in, what the special deals did you do? What damage can you do? It's gonna look like Zuckerberg and company on Capitol Hill, but worse, I think.

Jason Howell
17:49
So okay, my civic knowledge is not always uh on point. It's not something that, you know, it's uh it's it's something that I fully recognize I could do better to to learn more about it and to understand how it all works. But That so c uh House and Senate now blue.

18:05
You still have the Trump and the White House and their strategy Still have that executive branch. They're full in on this all you know, all in on the build-out and the and the friendships they've made with the the with the oligarchs that you're talking about. So what If you had to guess what the next two years like I understand that's the that's the likely direction that that's the dynamic that's at play here is like, well, we've been given a message that it's time to approach this differently.

18:34
But what can the what can actually be done to that end, given that the House and the Senate are blue, but the executive branch is still red?

Jeff Jarvis
18:43
And the courts are mixed.

Jason Howell
18:45
And the courts yeah, the courts are not necessarily don't know what you're gonna get. Or you know what you're gonna get and it's not very good.

Jeff Jarvis
18:54
Right. A few things. One is I don't think it's purely a blue issue. I think Republicans are gonna be grasping for things.

Jason Howell
19:02
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
19:02
Who make themselves and and and it's kind of, you know, who who loves Sam Altman? Who really wants to stand up for Sam Altman? Unless you were put in office by Peter Thiel and his money. Then you love Sam Altman.

Jason Howell
19:15
Yeah, right.

Jeff Jarvis
19:16
Uh and your JD Vance, you're gonna do that, and so on so forth. But there are Republicans I think who may even come across the eye. But let's say they don't. Even with the blue majorities, the first thing you have is the House's ability for oversight and hearings, both House and Senate.

19:31
So if they try to uh subpoena Hegh Odds are he's just gonna ignore it. Uh you you c you uh put him up for contempt. Who enforces that?

19:42
Department of Justice, they're not gonna go after him. That's that. Right?

Jason Howell
19:45
Right.

Jeff Jarvis
19:46
Uh the only thing they can do really is impeach him But if you're a corporate executive and you spent the last either two to six years buttering up the right wing that is now so resoundly defeated.

Jason Howell
20:02
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
20:03
You get a subpoena to appear on Capitol Hill. Hmm. And Fine. If you're if you're Mark Andreessen, if you're Peter Thiel, you're still going to be hostile. But if you're Jeff Bezos, and if you're his replacement And if you're Sundar Pichai, certainly, and if you're the new CEO of Apple.

Jason Howell
20:24
Zuckerberg.

Jeff Jarvis
20:25
And if you're Zuckerberg, even Zuckerberg who who sh shifted views, I mean his policy guy who put him in line with the Republicans just left.

Jason Howell
20:34
I don't

Jeff Jarvis
20:34
I think it's almost coincidental. They're gonna have A, they're gonna have to appear. They can't avoid it. And B they're gonna start singing different songs.

Jason Howell
20:44
I think so. They they seem to be uh pretty uh flip floppy, if that's the word.

Jeff Jarvis
20:51
Yeah, not not high on principle. That's

Jason Howell
20:54
yes, that's a great way to put it. That's that's that's a great way to put it.

Jeff Jarvis
20:57
And so the other part you get to is so I think they're gonna do a lot of dancing about stuff like regulation and uh oh no no no we're the good guys and so on and so forth, but they are gonna be pushed hard. The second thing is budgeting. You can't have a budget without the House.

21:12
So yes, any budget could get uh vetoed by by the executive. True. But at some point he needs a budget and if the republi if if he as the sole representative of republicanism um causes a government shutdown That's not good for all the people who want to who are looking at the next election.

21:33
So at some point I think the Democrats, depends on what they choose to use, do they want to defund ICE? Do they want to uh uh fix uh health care? Do they want to fix foreign aid?

21:45
Do they want to tax the billionaires? There's going to be some Matrix of those things that could affect these companies. Then the other thing that that I think matters here is the regulatory functions are executive functions.

22:05
So the SEC and such won't touch these companies for now. Uh they're safe. But they're they've got to recognize the chance of in only two years, the executive flipping is well to blue, and if both houses stay blue.

22:19
And if this they they redo the Supreme Court, they can't be sitting here acting like it's last year for the next two years. They've got to start changing strategy about how they operate

Jason Howell
22:31
So

Jeff Jarvis
22:32
I think there's a lot of subtlety here and how this goes. Now the other thing that's interesting to me, and then I'll shut up, which is a lie.

Jason Howell
22:38
I love it.

Jeff Jarvis
22:40
The billionaire tax again. It lost in California.

Jason Howell
22:47
It lost a little bit.

Jeff Jarvis
22:48
Right. And there was also the California is so amazingly screwed up because of these um initiatives that uh you can have one initiative on the ballot that contradicts another initiative on the ballot. So there were I think two other initiatives that basically would have avoided this initiative in any case and then there was an argument about how this one could be changed. It's all confusing.

Jason Howell
23:09
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
23:10
You've got to read a whole book, right, to vote in California. Right.

Jason Howell
23:13
Yep.

Jeff Jarvis
23:14
But I think it showed that if you could change it Something else would happen. And uh I think other states could do it. And so I think we're going to see taxation as a major issue on these companies.

23:31
So as you see these huge IPOs coming. As you see these big profits. And what happened to the stock market today?

Jason Howell
23:39
Oh it went up. Oh

Jeff Jarvis
23:40
no, it went up.

Jason Howell
23:40
Oh did it go up?

Jeff Jarvis
23:41
Oh yeah. Oh yeah.

Jason Howell
23:42
Oh I'm no no sorry. I'm thinking of Some of the some of these tech companies took a major hit.

Jeff Jarvis
23:46
Okay, we're gonna get to that. Right. So the Nasdaq is up 2%. Uh NVIDIA is down, last I looked. And really interestingly, SpaceX and Tesla took a major hit.

Jason Howell
23:58
Oh, big surprise.

Jeff Jarvis
23:59
Yeah, because m uh Elon Musk has lost uh I think a fair amount of clout.

Jason Howell
24:04
Yeah, I mean he was he's He's pretty closely tied to the way things have been the last couple of years in a lot of for a lot of different reasons, Doge and many other reasons. Exactly. Um he's become ki to to a large degree kind of a poster child I'd say for well yeah I I don't need to dance around it. He's become a poster child for the oligarch that you're talking about.

Jeff Jarvis
24:29
Yeah. Yeah absolutely

Jason Howell
24:30
is the symbol of that

Jeff Jarvis
24:31
So SpaceX is down, as we speak here on the day after the election, 3. 68 %.

Jason Howell
24:37
And

Jeff Jarvis
24:37
let's see Tesla. And he was planning to merge these two companies.

Jason Howell
24:41
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
24:42
Uh down 2. 35

Jason Howell
24:44
%. Mm-hmm.

Jeff Jarvis
24:46
Um Amazon is up seven point four four percent.

Jason Howell
24:52
Wow. Wow.

Jeff Jarvis
24:54
Because they took hits recently and now it's a it's a buying opportunity.

Jason Howell
24:58
Google

Jeff Jarvis
24:59
Alphabet is up four point two seven percent. Nvidia, let's see here, is down 1. 3 %, but I think that's um a lot of the it's still a complicated market

Jason Howell
25:10
Yeah. There has been a little bit of a cozying though. Jensen Wong is certainly in that camp of cozying up to the previous administration.

Jeff Jarvis
25:18
Right.

Jason Howell
25:19
And so you know that there's going to be some correction Potentially on his side. I I will be curious to see how this changes that dynamic, right? The the flip-flop kind of aspects of of how these companies do business, you know, um and how they uh course correct in the face of such a a major kind of shift in um in people's minds and their their votes that backed that.

Jeff Jarvis
25:44
I almost want to I I I I wouldn't know what I'm doing or where to go, but I almost wanna go down to Washington Decay Street. I wish I were there today and go into the bars tonight To hear the lobbyists for the various um technology companies who've had to spend all day changing strategy on a dock.

Jason Howell
26:00
Yeah, right. I need a drink.

Jeff Jarvis
26:04
Yep. Yep.

Jason Howell
26:07
Yeah. Well, and you know, tying into this um before we hit a break here is the anthropic IPO, which I think It's real interesting time because you got Anthropic, you got OpenAI, both of them, the the largest um you know, Frontier AI can uh companies. uh targeting you know the the biggest IPOs in on record and in history and that may still very well be true if you know when it happens. But that was happening in a version of the playbook that just got completely undone or rewritten or will be rewritten So how do you think this moment, the election and the the results of all of it and all this talk about oligarchs and data centers and everything, impacts this upcoming IPO for Anthropic? Does it does it have a direct impact or Or is anthropic suddenly in a position of like, oh shoot, I kind of wish we weren't doing this right now, and we had done it a couple of months ago or something, you know?

Jeff Jarvis
27:08
They're already swimming in the ocean. And I think that if they delayed it, it would look really bad.

Jason Howell
27:13
Yeah. Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
27:14
Um I mean I still think the val valuation is is absurd.

Jason Howell
27:18
Yes.

Jeff Jarvis
27:20
But the question is will there be enough to buy the stock at that absurd valuation? Um and the stock market's going up, as we said today. So in that sense, um yeah, the the risk is high.

27:33
One thing I didn't put in the rundown, um I saw a story about Oracle. uh in getting in deeper due because they've got they're borrowing I think twenty billion dollars between stock purchases and bonds Uh uh this is what we talked about last week. Ellison is is is highly, highly leveraged right now.

27:55
Um and Uh Anthropic has a purchase commitments of $895 billion

Jason Howell
28:02
as reported in the S1.

Jeff Jarvis
28:03
So there's a lot of other dominoes waiting for those checks.

Jason Howell
28:07
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
28:08
They count on as well. So I don't know, Jason, is anthropic too big not to IPO? Is it too big to fail?

Jason Howell
28:16
Right. Well, I mean we we've been asking that question about open AI for the last couple of years. Are they, you know, is open AI too big to fail? And you know, I wonder did did uh Is open AI, this is just pure guessing, a pure probably pure coincidence, but did open AI have you know, is their delay of IPO to next year part of like a a a potential kind of consideration of this this happening. I wonder about that.

Jeff Jarvis
28:45
I mean my I think I think everyone's guess was, or my guess was, I won't put it on anybody else, that anthropic pulled ahead of OpenAI and mainly because of their focus on code and uh and and claude's abilities. And so they Uh OpenAI said, you know, we're we're we're gonna be sloppy seconds. Um no. So I'm not sure it was because of the election or anything else, but I think they're in a more enviable position right now. Yeah.

Jason Howell
29:13
Sorry, say that again.

Jeff Jarvis
29:13
They're in an enviable position right now vis-a-vis the IPO because they can wait and do it in due time.

Jason Howell
29:19
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
29:19
Anthropic is a good idea.

Jason Howell
29:20
That's kind of how I'm feeling too. Yep. They're they're they're possibly there's they're breathing a sigh of relief so that they have the ability, you know, they they have the time on their side to be like, Look, we will get there It's it's not a matter of of if but when.

29:33
But now we don't feel this sudden pressure. Like it like if I was in anthropic shoes, I'd be far more nervous now than I was before Because holy moly, the ground just shifted underneath you and you're kind of already, like you said, you're already on that train track going to your destination. So we'll see what happens.

Jeff Jarvis
29:51
You have Elizabeth Ward who sent them four pages of questions. They can't necessarily subpoena them to a hearing right now, but they can they can put a lot of heat on um on them. The other thing about about OpenAI was they had a they were doing another capital raise and it came in short of what they wanted and the evaluation was lower. So um it's caution time for them.

Jason Howell
30:16
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Jeff Jarvis
30:18
So uh let's see another uh so that we're starting to get more information about anthropic. They had 17 billion dollars in in Q3 revenue. That's new figures that got added into their S1.

30:30
Um and that's inspect that's an impressive number, no question about it. I just I still don't really understand where all that's coming from. As I think we said I think they have mainly five customers.

30:40
They're vulnerable there. Who are we don't know who those customers are. We don't know what value they're in turn getting out of this.

30:46
I still think there's a fair house of cards here.

Jason Howell
30:50
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. But

Jeff Jarvis
30:52
Anthropic says they are ever more powerful

Jason Howell
30:57
They say they're ever more powerful. Oh, that's right. Oh, I almost forgot about that. I was about to go to a break, but there is the RC the RSI, the recursive self-improvement. uh now buried inside of the risk factors is basically saying um that they believe that their future models, they estimate anyways that their future models uh indicate that we may imminently meet the responsible scaling policies definition of this uh recursive self-improvement, uh dramatically accelerated progress attributable to AI, which is essentially AI Speeding up the building of the next AI.

Jeff Jarvis
31:34
Which doesn't necessarily mean evil and destruction.

Jason Howell
31:38
No.

Jeff Jarvis
31:39
It just means it's more powerful than what it can do, but also you can control it more.

Jason Howell
31:43
I mean AI is is doing a lot in building all sorts of other things via code, so it makes you know and and They are you all of these companies are using their uh AI, their current AI or their future AI to develop fur further down the road, like they're using it in some way, shape, or form. This is this sounds more like An AI that just can just kind of go full auto, develop the next thing, and you you can imagine that just that accelerates the other. Yeah, it feeds

Jeff Jarvis
32:11
into the prior discussion about regulation. Yeah. Because oh my god, because there are th the doomers are out there saying, oh but it can do this, that's when it can destroy the earth.

Jason Howell
32:18
That's that's the point at which it's it's too dangerous.

Jeff Jarvis
32:21
Yes, yes. But meanwhile, just to get ready, in case it can kill us all, in case it does become our all-powerful new master, Anthropic says that we really should not be mean to Claude.

Jason Howell
32:34
I didn't read this one. Tell me about it. I didn't read this. It's not about feelings.

Jeff Jarvis
32:42
So in their in their AI usage policy, um Along with banning it from bioweapons and illegal drugs, they added a new line. Users should not, quote, engage in sustained and needless abusive or cruel behavior toward our models. They want the ability to end uh conversations with people who are persistently harmful or abusive, which presumes that you can abuse a lawnmower.

Jason Howell
33:10
Right? That's a good way to put it. What yeah, but what are you doing when you throw away a lawnmower that doesn't work anymore? Are you

Jeff Jarvis
33:16
Poor thing? Don't you think it was

Jason Howell
33:18
giving up on the thing?

Jeff Jarvis
33:19
Yeah. Get a spark plug for God's sakes.

Jason Howell
33:25
Seriously. So okay. So i if you're anthropic, why?

33:32
Is this a more is this a morality stance? To say like, hey, we need a we need a friendlier world and so therefore this is like one way that we can tip the scales to make people be friendlier or to not outwardly be mean? Or Is this them saying our models are our our AI is so like humans that it too has feelings and don't do that?

33:52
Or I don't even know what it means.

Jeff Jarvis
33:55
I I don't really see a rationale in here from from Anthropic.

Jason Howell
33:59
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
33:59
Um Mustafa Suleiman made fun of them. And said that we shouldn't be concerned about their feelings. They don't have them.

34:08
Thank you very much for a rational thought here. But it's just the absurdity that these people are going to be worth $2 trillion? Jesus.

34:17
It's just it's an upside down topsy turvy world recover here.

Jason Howell
34:22
There was a time when I said thank you at the end of my prompts. I still say please.

Jeff Jarvis
34:27
Just because it's a habit it comes out. Yeah, sometimes it

Jason Howell
34:29
sometimes it comes out. It's a but yeah. I mean, yeah, I don't know. I don't know, that's a funny one. I miss that one.

Jeff Jarvis
34:38
But you know, people like me could regret my tough stance

Jason Howell
34:42
You know, there may be a time when ClaudeBots are walking the earth and they remember. They don't forget anything unless it sits outside of their context window and they have to flush it out and summarize it And maybe in the process of summarizing it, they drop the exact thing you said and just kind of allude to you saying

Jeff Jarvis
35:00
Jarvis is a jerk. And the world would be better off without him. Yeah.

Jason Howell
35:07
Eliminated. All right. We're going to take a break.

35:12
Before we do, I do want to thank our amazing uh patrons at patreon. com slash AI Inside Show. Few of you of note, John Garrison, Tim Epperson, just a couple of our amazing patrons who uh yeah, who support us on a deeper level at Patreon, uh which supports the health of this show.

35:31
Enjoy hopefully the AI Inside Daily Podcast. I had a technical issue on Monday, so you got a supersized version of it on Tuesday yesterday, but Um, you know, hey, I I try to always come through even if I mess it up.

Jeff Jarvis
35:44
It's like getting two slices of cake.

Jason Howell
35:47
Yes. But just a little slice. The cake isn't perfectly fresh and moist necessarily.

35:54
The crusts are, you know, a little a little bit not in a good way. Yes. Exactly.

36:02
So patreon. com slash AI Inside Show. If you like the the taste of the cake that we're cooking or we're baking, come on over and uh Help us out.

36:10
Uh, we're gonna take a break when we come back. I think we have some fun stories to bat around, including Google saying it's AI search or nothing, school kids. That's coming up here in a moment Google has a new a new plan for its relations with schools, kind of like a new deal that it's cutting with schools, basically saying next year Uh Google plans to turn off its AI tools for K through twelve students unless school admins choose to turn them on, right?

36:45
It's It's so what is that? So the turn it off if it 's on by default. Oh the default becomes off and it's only on the side of the side.

Jeff Jarvis
36:57
According to TechCrunch plans to disable the tools for K-12. Unless administrators explicitly turn them on. So it's a good idea. Okay.

Jason Howell
37:03
So it's opt-in, not opt-out. And so um, you know, because a lot of schools and a lot of parents, I imagine, as well. are nervous about their kids using generative AI, say we don't want them using Gemini at school, whatever, and Google, you know, the the Chromebooks are everywhere, so Don't let them use that.

37:22
Don't let them new use notebook, even though notebook is a really great tool for um for classwork, I would imagine. Um Gemini in Classroom and Google search Wait a minute, what? So Google search going away for for students?

37:36
Uh if the school restricts AI, basically it loses Google search entirely because Google is saying that search and AI are so deeply integrated that you can't possibly remove one from the other. They're just gonna not have access to search entirely. It's unavailable.

Jeff Jarvis
37:51
So this is all predictably getting anger from people, people uh abusing this. I saw somebody who says, I used to work at Google, this is BS, they could do this Um I my default here is that uh number one, AI is so deeply integrated into search, I don't see how you would separate it. Out.

Jason Howell
38:12
I think there are ways.

Jeff Jarvis
38:14
Well then the second thing is they have they're changing the user interface here. In that you can now when you get to the one box, whatever they call it, you can ask it questions. You can have a dialogue with it.

38:29
You are then right then in Google, you're not going to Gemini, you're not going anywhere else, but you are you are having a chat discussion. Through that box in what is now Google. And that is how that funk that that service operates in all ways.

38:45
So I don't see how you turn that off and revert to only keywords. Don't ask me a full question. I can't do anything.

38:53
I don't think it's easily separable anymore. Unless you literally reverted to an old Google, but but even then, um I don't know how it's architected. I don't know how you do that.

Jason Howell
39:06
Yeah, I mean when you look at a Google search box right now, when I pull it up You know, yeah, like you said, this search box is for all accounts, it's a j it's a Gemini.

Jeff Jarvis
39:19
So so if you type in there explain gravity to me. Right. It's not going to come up with 10 blue links. It is going to um

Jason Howell
39:29
It's going to give me

Jeff Jarvis
39:30
It's giving you a one-box description, right? With with illustration and everything, right? So you're you're already in a chat interface. Full stop.

Jason Howell
39:38
Yeah, I mean if I if I didn't know that I got here through Google search, I would think that I was in Gemini. It certainly looks a whole lot like Gemini. I can add in You know, I can create images from here, add in images into the query or whatever.

39:51
Keep going down. Oh, and then that box goes away. So basically the box uh goes up and now we get to the blue links.

Jeff Jarvis
39:57
But even then it's interspersed with more explanation, different features and other kinds of things. So so that then the problem for Google becomes, well where's the line? No chat Oh oh okay.

40:10
No chat. Then if a student asks us a question we have to say um I can't help you with that. That's chatting, by the way.

40:17
Um only blue links. Well, that's not how search is now architected at Google.

Jason Howell
40:25
Yeah. I mean it's the legacy thought of it's the the legacy view of what search is is You know, I put in a query, it gives me a bunch of links, I decide which link to push. So if I go into this more section, I get web. If I go there, this is just web search.

Jeff Jarvis
40:43
It's a very good point. Yep

Jason Howell
40:45
So there's that.

Jeff Jarvis
40:47
Scroll down there, would you?

Jason Howell
40:49
Oh, sorry.

Jeff Jarvis
40:50
See if see if it breaks out of that. Nope, it's all blue links.

Jason Howell
40:53
Yeah, it's all blue links. Okay, all right.

Jeff Jarvis
40:55
That's a really good point, Jason. There it is. Okay.

40:57
All right. All right. I stand modified.

Jason Howell
41:00
There is now mind you I did not come up with this. We talked about this on DTNS yesterday. Uh Tom Merritt pointed out a few alternatives that Okay so I wasn't even aware that the web was a destination you could get to So there's that.

41:12
That seems like an easy one. I don't know how easy it is to decouple or turn off the other things, but you know, mind you, there is a there is a place you can go where you just get web zer uh web results. There is also a um Something you can add, and I haven't tested this, so let's test it.

41:29
Explain gravity to me and UDM equals 14 If I do this, no, that didn't work. So my understanding is that this is supposed to turn off the AI overview thing. But it doesn't look like it does.

41:47
So that is not a thing. So I guess the web tab. Yeah, I guess could Google, could you just activate the web tab and deactivate the AI Mode tab?

Jeff Jarvis
41:55
But look but looking at the thing.

Jason Howell
41:57
I don't know the architecture to make that happen.

Jeff Jarvis
41:59
And what are you taking away from students? Well

Jason Howell
42:02
, that's another that's another issue.

Jeff Jarvis
42:03
That's another issue. But I think it's another issue. You're denuding it.

42:07
And if you don't use Google For search. I mean uh let's let's say uh what's what's it called? Bing.

Jason Howell
42:14
What other kind of searches even exist anymore?

Jeff Jarvis
42:17
Uh explain gravity to me. So boy, Microsoft, you're behind. It's blue links.

Jason Howell
42:28
It's like I don't know what gravity is. Uh explain gravity to me.

Jeff Jarvis
42:34
So it's blue links. That's Wikipedia.

Jason Howell
42:39
Oh, that's Wikipedia. Okay. Yep. Yep. You're right.

Jeff Jarvis
42:41
And it summarizes Wikipedia. It does do a little AI magic on that, but it's still Wikipedia. Um

Jason Howell
42:48
okay. Okay. That's pretty light though by comparison.

Jeff Jarvis
42:53
It does ask an adds possible questions in.

Jason Howell
42:57
Does it have a web? No.

Jeff Jarvis
42:59
No.

Jason Howell
43:00
Interesting. Oops. It does have an AI mode specifically where you go into the obvious kind of AI conversation interface.

43:10
Okay. But the all tab is essentially the w I mean it's not. There is a little bit of AI going on.

43:17
A little bit. It's not nearly as as uh fully integrated and and everything as Google has on its yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
43:26
So I don't know the the thing with the what what what strikes me about this is that it it seems that Google started this. Discussion. Rather than having a school administrator out there who screamed, we won't use Google unless they , okay, well, this is the deal.

43:39
They seem to come up with this policy after having talked with administrators. So I just don't fully understand how this how they got here because it's not great PR. That's that's Google.

Jason Howell
43:49
Yeah, yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
43:50
They don't always handle the internet.

Jason Howell
43:51
They should have a t-shirt. Google. Not great PR. Not good PR

Jeff Jarvis
43:55
or branding.

Jason Howell
43:55
Branding. Or branding, yes.

Jeff Jarvis
43:57
Good products, not great PR and branding.

Jason Howell
44:01
The stick to itedness is not always great either. Um keeping things out of the killed by Google uh graveyard, that's a challenge. Yeah, but I do think, you know, touching back on what you were talking about There's that.

44:14
There's the technicality, the technical capability or incapability of removing AI from search. There's also what are we doing with students at a time when AI is this, you know, emerging and incredibly important technology, we're we're teaching them that that that's a tool that they absolutely cannot use, even though they will, they're just not going to use it there. And we're not teaching them the skills to be to use it as a critical user.

44:41
Right. You know, because like s a lot of people will say, Well they're gonna get wrong answers from the AI. And it's like, yeah, you know, that's kind of how the technology works.

44:48
And so as you work with it, you start to understand how to get it to say how to how to either check it or you know check the the links that it offers or use it as a starting point and not as the overall truth and these are skills that you don't immediately just inherit the first time you use AI. You kinda have to use it a little bit before you get that understanding. And that's kind of what school's all about, is teaching you how to do things, you know, with a with a a a healthy perspective, I guess

Jeff Jarvis
45:17
Yeah. Yeah, so I think there's more nuanced ways to present this. And I understand, I mean, K through 12 for God's sakes. Yeah, if you're first grade.

Jason Howell
45:29
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
45:30
Um

Jason Howell
45:31
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
45:31
How do I make a bomb? Um right. But it's the whole world. You're bringing the whole world's information in, and there's no predicting what it's going to bring in, and there's risk there. But so is there in a library.

Jason Howell
45:46
Yeah. Yeah. That's always been the case that it's you know that the the web brings with it the possibility for seeing things that you don't want to see and I don't know.

45:58
I don't know. I mean as a parent Like I don't necessarily Yeah, I I think at the end of the day as a parent, I don't want an education for my kids to pretend like AI doesn't exist. I feel like that sets them up for failure.

46:14
or for potential disaster because they just don't know what they don't know, you know? Um

Jeff Jarvis
46:21
Yeah, and so so you set outcomes and you you set the pedagogy so that you know what skills you're gonna teach them.

Jason Howell
46:28
Yeah, figure out how you how you uh healthfully or r or responsibly integrate AI into the curriculum in a way that teaches them how to use it properly and how to not use it improperly. Yeah. Yeah.

46:44
Agreed. Motion carried. Um okay, another another one.

46:50
This is data from Active Track. That says uh the work uh this is an analytics company, uh basically for workplace um workplace analytics company. They sell monitoring software I can only show you so much of this Bloomberg article.

47:06
At least it shows you the headline. On New York Times, when I pull up their their uh unlogged in state, it doesn't even show you the headline anymore. It just shows you like a word or two.

47:16
It's so frustrating. Anyways, uh Active Track tracked computer activity for more than 9,000 workers at 467 companies. uh for a few months, April through September, and they found that AI users work days ran eight and a half to nine point one hours long.

47:35
Whereas users who were not using AI, their work days were less, 7. 6 hours by comparison. Um 90 minutes longer basically when you're using AI.

47:49
Heavier AI users also had shorter focus. sessions, about 38 minutes versus like 48 uh for users who might use AI lightly by comparison. So what does that mean?

48:02
That heavy AI users have less Or it seems to imply that they have less ability to focus on a single task? Or does that mean that the AI is making them more efficient so they need to spend more Less time on something? I don't know how you

Jeff Jarvis
48:16
think the the the hope of the argument is by the way, one little trick, Jason, besides the illegal ways to get content, is I found Bloomberg syndicates enough That if you put the

Jason Howell
48:25
device

Jeff Jarvis
48:26
in search, you'll find a rewrite of it somewhere else.

Jason Howell
48:29
Right.

Jeff Jarvis
48:29
So right now on Gizmodo, I'm reading a quote. That AI may help employees complete tasks faster, but our research shows it contributes to longer workdays, more application switching, and shorter focus sessions. Um a few of possible interpretations.

48:44
One is that um they're getting more done and feeling more effective. Another is they're enjoying it more. Another is that their bosses are saying, oh, now I'm gonna throw more work on you because you're more efficient.

48:57
Uh another is, oh, this is a slop I gotta get through to get my job done. It's worse.

Jason Howell
49:02
Mm-hmm. They don't know.

Jeff Jarvis
49:04
I don't know.

Jason Howell
49:06
Yeah, very interesting. Um Active Track uh representatives said AI may help employees complete tasks faster, but our research shows it contributes to longer work days.

Jeff Jarvis
49:21
It's early research.

Jason Howell
49:23
Early research. Correlation doesn't always mean causation, blah, blah, blah. There's that.

49:32
And OpenAI had its own survey that that kind of found the opposite. Of course it's OpenAI, but they said of 9,000 workers a year ago, back in December, people said AI saved them 40 to 60 minutes a day. So I don't know.

49:48
Who knows? I guess it depends on who who it's coming from. Um but you know, I can kinda When I think about yesterday, last night, you know, the Tuesdays are my long day.

49:59
And I had a very busy day, multiple podcasts, talk to you know people. Um Building out rundowns for this show and our Android Faithful like I was very, very jammed. And at the end of of Android Faithful, I was also working with chat GPT to create a process that would make some of my post-production work with Android Faithful a little easier.

50:21
And I didn't step away from here for like two hours after Android Faithful ended. And I was fine with it because I was really like in the mode of like, I want to figure out this system and everything like that. But in that case, like I would have walked away two hours prior, but I chose not to because I was Yeah, so invested in building this tool, but maybe that's for the same thing.

50:43
That's true. Yeah, totally. I don't I don't blame the tool for that

Jeff Jarvis
50:47
Right.

Jason Howell
50:48
I blame my own inability to turn it off because I was inspired in the moment, you know?

Jeff Jarvis
50:53
Yep.

Jason Howell
50:53
So at least there's that. Lee, thank you for the super chat. Lee is watching the live stream. On our YouTube channel, AI Inside Show says, and I think this uh ties in with the Google and schools story that we were just talking about, says Maybe I'm completely wrong on this, but Google has used machine learning tools in their search product for 25 years.

Jeff Jarvis
51:13
Yes.

Jason Howell
51:13
Difference between machine learning tools and modern generative AI, I'd say there's probably a difference there, right? Like Generative AI is a different ball of wax versus using machine learning behind the scenes on what are the right search results to appear and that sort of stuff. But I get where you're coming from, Lee. I don't know. What do you think about that?

Jeff Jarvis
51:36
Um

Jason Howell
51:38
same, same but different?

Jeff Jarvis
51:40
Yeah, I think I I think we're we're there now where companies are trying to find I think the the the uh token maxing age has already ended. It's too expensive.

Jason Howell
51:49
Yes.

Jeff Jarvis
51:50
It's giving money to uh the big companies. Um the open weight models provide opportunities. I think the key will be how it mixes, how you do something with the open weight model and then you have the expensive model check it. Or check the security on it or whatever, um, or do the tasks that it couldn't otherwise do.

Jason Howell
52:09
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Jeff Jarvis
52:10
So I I think this is going to be the trend. And again, this goes to the anthropic and open AI um IPOs because I think this is going to present huge use and price competition for them. They're integrable. That's not a word. You can integrate them

Jason Howell
52:31
You're talking about the open models doing 90% of agentic work, is that right?

Jeff Jarvis
52:35
Yes. Is that where we

Jason Howell
52:37
No, no, so so Lee was talking about the Google.

Jeff Jarvis
52:40
Oh Lee's comment. Oh, I'm sorry. I I I

Jason Howell
52:42
apologize.

Jeff Jarvis
52:45
Yeah, I agree, Lee. I think and I I think you raise a good point, Lee, because it it's sorry, no, I'm blathering back. Um is if Google had to warrant we're giving students no AI, they kind of can't.

Jason Howell
53:01
Yeah, that's where's that line?

Jeff Jarvis
53:03
It's behind the scenes.

Jason Howell
53:04
How do you define it? How deep do you go to defining it?

Jeff Jarvis
53:07
Where do we get in trouble? So you don't want AI? Okay. You don't get AI.

Jason Howell
53:11
Yeah, yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
53:11
It's it's like uh uh Street View in Germany. Where at some point Google just said, okay, fine, no street view for you. No soup for you.

Jason Howell
53:22
Yeah, yeah. That that makes a lot of sense. Thank you, Lee.

53:25
That's o that's okay. But you've set up our next story very nicely, which is you've giv you given the argument. Now we just need to know what it's what it's based on.

53:37
Gartner has this new report on open models and uh essentially what it means or what they're the headline of it is open weight models will run 90% of it enterprise agentic workflow steps which basically is saying nine in ten steps an AI agent takes are actually very routine And classifying things, calling tools, checking data, all that kind of stuff doesn't actually necessarily always require some sort of frontier model working in the cloud to do it effectively. that open weight models can handle a lot of this at parity for a quarter of the price of the cheapest closed model. And for the enterprise That's potentially a really big deal.

54:18
And I basically and basically it sounds like Gardner is saying um by twenty thirty, ninety percent of those operational agent steps uh run on open weight models. And the remaining 10%, which is, you know, probably relegated to like RD research, deeper research and development, that sort of stuff, would happen with the frontier models. Also the harnesses, I think that are directing the agents from the open models would still have access to those frontier models for when they need them to do those certain things.

54:46
I don't know how that changes the dynamics, the pricing dynamics of those frontier companies and what they offer But um yeah, I totally agree with this. I think it 's

Jeff Jarvis
54:57
so I've got a question for you. Um asking for a friend, my son. Uh You you start to use Claude at some length and then before you know it, you're buying more tokens because you're in the middle of something and you hit your time window or your token window or whatever.

55:13
And then before you know it, you have a huge bill And so the only way that I know of right now to effectively run open weight models is to buy a very expensive ten thousand dollar machine. Or two of them and do it locally. Are there hosted do you know of any ways that you can run open weights in a hosted environment so you don't have to own the hardware?

55:35
And so yes, you pay

Jason Howell
55:37
in the cloud.

Jeff Jarvis
55:38
Yeah, you pay you pay a time or token usage fee on the open weight model, but you don't have to own the hardware. You know of anything like that? I don't. I think it's a heaven. I would have to. If you go to Hugging Face, you can download anything, but if you don't have the hardware, you can't run them.

Jason Howell
56:02
Because that's assuming that you're running them locally. I mean, like when I think of Llama, which was is still is, I don't know, but was uh meta 's kind of open model uh architecture or whatever, you could still run Llama in the cloud on serv services, right?

Jeff Jarvis
56:22
Right, right. So I just wonder if it's if it's a business yet. So I just searched on uh this just came up this morning that's why I'm asking now.

56:29
Um uh featherless. ai , sponsored result. Host any open source Um AI, no GPU management.

56:39
All done in the cloud.

Jason Howell
56:40
Yeah, I'd be really surprised if you couldn't do this. I'm trying to think if I have any confirmed like services. Like we had a previous sponsor, Aria. Or area, sorry. Area, uh, open models in the cloud, and I'm sure that they have Uh I think at a c

Jeff Jarvis
56:59
obviously at a c at a corporate level that's the case. It's what it's what Palantir does to an extent. Right?

57:07
Um with their harness. But I would think you'd get to a point where there's just a cons there's a there's a it's not a big business yet because you have to be pretty geeky to do it. But if there's a geeky way Uh to do it.

57:21
I've not seen a lot of things popping up here.

Jason Howell
57:26
Yeah, it's a good question. I mean I wanna say that yes, this exists. But I'm not entirely sure right in this moment how to how to kind of confirm that. Um I just, you know, cuz uh uh because like it like I said, like uh Llama was Meta 's version of this early on. Right, but you can

Jeff Jarvis
57:48
you can download Llama and you can use it.

Jason Howell
57:51
But I could interact with it on the web too through certain services. Like I could find it

Jeff Jarvis
57:56
posted. Yes, you could, yes, yes, yes.

Jason Howell
57:58
And I so I imagine that's the case for the chunks and the all the other things as well, you know? Yes. I I'd be really surprised if you couldn't do that in one way, shape, or form. But because not because to your point, not everybody's going to Buy the machine.

Jeff Jarvis
58:18
Or be able to get them.

Jason Howell
58:20
Yeah, yeah, right. Or even be able to get them at all. Yeah, it's true.

Jeff Jarvis
58:24
All right. Well if anybody folks out there know of these options, let me know.

Jason Howell
58:28
Yeah, let us know. Contact at ai insight. show if you want to send us an email. Um let's see here. What else? Do do do do

Jeff Jarvis
58:37
Jensen Wong

Jason Howell
58:39
Oh, Jensen Wong. That's right. Let me find the story.

Jeff Jarvis
58:43
So this was a story last week in the Times.

Jason Howell
58:46
Yeah. What do you think about this one? This is uh this is kind of You know, this is a little bit more kind of along the lines of like, ooh, something going on behind the scenes.

58:56
Do does somebody know something we don't about Jensen Wong? And I don't know, it could be innocent, it could be whatever, but New York Times reported last week that US intelligence officials um have basically concluded that an executive at a Singapore data center company called Megaspeed was a Chinese intelligence agent or asset. Her name, Alice Wong, no relation to Jensen Wong, but um they had surveillance that showed that she had a close relationship with Jensen Wong.

59:27
Um Uh photograph together, blah blah blah, at a restaurant, blah blah blah. Um but they were kind of thinking or inferring that um there might be some sort of like deal making behind the scenes to get around some of these these China US um roadblocks. Am I understanding this correctly?

Jeff Jarvis
59:45
I thought it was a very flimsy story in the times.

Jason Howell
59:48
It sounded f yes. The more I thought about it, the more I was like, all right, this This might be

Jeff Jarvis
59:54
it's kind of dropped. I mean here we have um uh who was it uh Tom's hardware is kind of picking it up, but I don't think we saw it picked up uh necessarily anywhere else. Yeah the journey the journal might have done a version of it Um first Jensen Wong is savvy as hell.

01:00:09
He is Taiwanese, I believe, but he understands Chinese politics. He understands all the ins and outs of dealing with China. Um so it's not like he's some innocent waif who comes along uh and and wouldn't understand what's going on and all the risks involved.

01:00:27
He's doing business he was doing business with this woman. And uh uh you know, I've had I don't want to besmirch um students, but I've had people say to me in universities that you have to be careful Around Chinese students, not because they're spies, but because they could be spied upon. And that if you if if you induce them to say something that was controversial about the government

Jason Howell
01:00:53
Mm-hmm.

Jeff Jarvis
01:00:54
Who knows who else is in the class who could spy on right? So And Jensen Walk is plenty savvy, number one. Number two, this whole has a relationship with Yeah. Tabloid-y and and super

Jason Howell
01:01:13
tabloid-y.

Jeff Jarvis
01:01:13
Yeah, it it it was it there was nothing to back it up. It was irresponsible. And then three um Nvidia said the next day, uh there was an investigation of this relationship. It turned up nothing of this of this woman. It turned up no evidence that uh of the chip is being sent or this or that, and there's nothing here

Jason Howell
01:01:32
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
01:01:33
So yeah, I think I think this is a this was an effort by the Times to try to make

Jason Howell
01:01:38
Oh, there's something going on.

Jeff Jarvis
01:01:40
Yep.

Jason Howell
01:01:40
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, and I think I fell for for it initially and actually when I was putting the show together I I started having mixed feelings about the story. Kind of that whole tablet.

Jeff Jarvis
01:01:50
I think it's worthwhile for us to maybe point out the flimsy nature of it

Jason Howell
01:01:54
Yeah, for sure, for sure. It doesn't quite seem like there's a there there, but um nonetheless there you go. Thank you for all that background.

01:02:04
I think that's important. Uh real quick, if you're enjoying this show, uh make sure and leave us a review on Apple Podcasts. It's a huge help.

01:02:11
helps get the word out, helps show that people are watching and listening, uh including uh people who might someday want to sponsor the the show itself. So uh thank you very much for that. We're gonna take a break And uh when we come back, we got a few quick items to get to before we get you out of here.

01:02:27
So hang tight. All right, so this is a story, a quick kind of update um on the anthropic, openai, meta , google, all those companies having these AI models that are escape, you know, they're escaping Uh their testing environments and a lot of stories have happened in the to this regard in the last six months. Well, there is a security firm behind a lot of those tests.

01:02:56
that is now basically taking ownership, saying that it was an error on their part. And the firm is called irregular. It's out of Tel Aviv.

01:03:05
It runs security tests. for these companies. CEO Dan Lahave at a Bloomberg event basically said the isolation guards were not set up as they were intended.

01:03:16
So he's basically saying, look, this this wasn't necessarily a matter of these agents being so wicked smart and crafty that they they started doing all of these things on their own and everything. This was really d about, according to them, uh humans that didn't set up a test environment properly. Which is something that we've been saying on this show in recent weeks.

01:03:39
Uh you know, is is that you know doesn't automatically mean that these things are so smart that now suddenly they're gonna take over the world. At the core, they're just looking for holes. They're looking for accessible you know, ex uh ways to access and accomplish the tasks that they've been given And if we don't do our due diligence as humans as setting up a proper environment for to test within, then they're gonna find the way out.

01:04:05
And uh that that responsibility lies in the hands of the human. So human error, not actually rogue AI. Do you feel any better?

Jeff Jarvis
01:04:13
Um yeah. I I I think this goes back to our discussion about regulation earlier. I I think that there there's not some magic organization that's going to solve all problems.

01:04:23
But I do think that that when there were the breakouts from open AI The security firms that were called upon were questioned in relation to their independence of OpenAI and of Tusk Real boomer stuff. Doomer stuff. So I think we're going to need uh kind of an underwriter's laboratories for AI testing such that there's an independence that you can call upon.

01:04:49
And they need to be funded by the AI companies, but independent of them. So when radio started, advertisers wanted to know how large the audience was, and the networks provided their own data to them. So this are larger audiences.

01:05:00
And the advertisers said, We don't believe you. And so separate rating companies were set up, Nielsen and such eventually.

Jason Howell
01:05:08
Right.

Jeff Jarvis
01:05:09
And others in the early rating days and broadcast, but also in print, uh there was what used to be called the Audit Bureau of Circulations. that is now called so the Association of Audited Media. I was on the original digital committee for them, deciding what a page view was.

01:05:25
And they were independent of the publishers and would then be trusted by the advertisers to audit. Even then, some advertisers didn't trust it, and they insisted on doing their own audits, but whatever Um so this whole question of who's at fault when it breaks out will define the environment, define breaking out, define who as reporting on this, there has to be more independence. I think that's going to be a pretty quick fallout, even from the election.

01:05:55
Is this going to be something that the industry has to offer up? Is funding some independent um auditing uh organizations.

Jason Howell
01:06:04
Good. Yeah, and that'll that'll be uh a welcome change.

Jeff Jarvis
01:06:08
Yep, but it'll be changeable as hell because you know the the clever AI will invent something new we didn't we didn't anticipate.

Jason Howell
01:06:15
We couldn't have possibly known that it would be so clever. We have OpenAI finally merging chat and work tabs. This is something that Enthropic actually merged back back in September.

01:06:28
It's kind of the converging of their their standard mode and their work mode, which is where it, you know, integrates with like files in your computer and computer control and cloud and all that kind of stuff, browser control and everything. Um and so uh ChatGPT is kind of bringing them all together. Codecs will stay separated from that separate mode, uh, but they will share uh one usage pool with that mode.

01:06:54
So, you know, that might mean that users will hit limits sooner because of the combined nature of that. But uh there you go. It's a small change, but you know, one less thing for you as a user to have to ask yourself, should I be in this mode?

01:07:09
Should I be in that mode? They just kind of all do the same thing for the most part now. So

Jeff Jarvis
01:07:14
Thank you for that.

Jason Howell
01:07:15
Yeah. I've definitely been using Chat GPT a lot more. I've also been using uh Gemini a lot more.

01:07:20
I've been really expanding and using each of them and and kind of pitting them against each other someday. I'll uh talk about some of the strengths between them. Um Apple Watch has this AI listening feature that we've talked about called live rewind.

01:07:35
It's now in beta. So if you have the series 12 or Ultra 4 uh and you're in the l the the beta the active beta then you might have access to this. You double press on the crown, the digital crown And you'll get text of the last 15 seconds of conversation that appears on your watch.

01:07:53
So it's kind of collecting this in real time Uh no speaker IDs, you don't get any raw audio saved, so there's that, no verbatim transcript of the entire conversation. It's just the last 15 seconds, and when you do it A chime rings so the other person knows. If the other person actually knows what a chime means.

01:08:13
Does a chime count as consent? Who knows, you know? It's not like when you're uh when you're on a call and and someone hits record and it's like recording the call so that you know exactly what's going on.

01:08:26
It's just a chime

Jeff Jarvis
01:08:28
I think people are going to be nervous about this, number one. Number two, lawyers are going to make hay on this because if you're in a two-party state and both parties need to consent, the chime will probably not be seen as adequate. And I mean what happens when uh you're on a Zoom call and someone decides to record it? You now constantly have to hear the voice. This call is being recorded.

Jason Howell
01:08:49
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
01:08:51
Um used to be back in the day. You probably never experienced this, Jason. Back in the day, Uncle Jeff tells me uh that if a phone call was being recorded, uh there was a beep you were supposed to present on the phone calls people knew. Very similarly.

Jason Howell
01:09:07
Oh. So

Jeff Jarvis
01:09:07
there's a press there. Yeah. I don't know.

01:09:11
I mean if a radio station if a reporter uh recorded you, uh I wonder if I can Google this. A phone recording beep is an audible tone, a half second burst at 1400 Hz every 15 sec every 15 seconds. Played during a telephone call to let all participants know the conversation is being recorded.

Jason Howell
01:09:36
Oh, okay. I feel like I've heard that before.

Jeff Jarvis
01:09:40
Um

Jason Howell
01:09:41
yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
01:09:42
And but I think again, just as you pointed out, did everybody know what that meant? Was this a drain beep in somebody's phone call?

Jason Howell
01:09:50
Okay. But there

Jeff Jarvis
01:09:50
there is a precedent for that.

Jason Howell
01:09:52
Okay. Okay. I wonder how loud it is too off that tiny little watch. Would it really be Loud enough for the other person to do.

Jeff Jarvis
01:09:59
Well if you if you if you search for recorder warning tone on Wikipedia right now, you can play it.

Jason Howell
01:10:06
Oh boy, did we want to do that?

Jeff Jarvis
01:10:08
Recorder warning tone.

Jason Howell
01:10:10
Let's see here. This is gonna require recorder. Warning.

Speaker 3
01:10:15
Recorder warning tone.

Jason Howell
01:10:17
You've got your

Speaker 3
01:10:20
recorder warning. Recorder warning tone.

Jason Howell
01:10:24
We've got a feedback.

Jeff Jarvis
01:10:26
Yeah, it's not doing anything. I don't oh there was the tone.

Jason Howell
01:10:29
Oh I heard it. Okay.

Jeff Jarvis
01:10:33
Okay, now I can share

Jason Howell
01:10:34
I can share it through the actual here. Let's see. Okay, mute on your side.

Jeff Jarvis
01:10:40
Okay, if

Jason Howell
01:10:40
we gotta hear the tone. Oh, that's pleasant. So hi did you hear that?

Jeff Jarvis
01:10:46
Yes.

Jason Howell
01:10:47
Okay, yeah. That's a pleasant audio.

Jeff Jarvis
01:10:50
So I remember that tone from back in the day because I also remember old-fashioned phones, kids, with Liars.

Jason Howell
01:10:58
By the way, by the way, Jeff, I'm recording this podcast. And you notice because the tone plays every ten seconds for all of our listeners throughout the entirety of the podcast. Uh boy, that would not encourage people to uh sub keep subscribed.

01:11:15
Oh well Uh what else do we have here? Let's see here. We've got nope, we talked about that.

01:11:22
Apple restricting dating apps and AI companions to users 18 and up. So starting November 16th, there's going to be a new uh App Store age rating category called Dating and Relationships. It will cover apps connecting real people, of course, but also virtual companion apps um you know sexual and romantic content obviously included in that it'll get an automatic 18 plus rating So this would be for you know the apps like replica and character.

01:11:52
ai, maybe it rest in peace. Um they would they would be included in this. So that makes sense.

Jeff Jarvis
01:12:00
Yeah

Jason Howell
01:12:01
that makes a lot of sense to me. And finally, Anthropic confirmed it's steering its clod code away from cloning games. So a lot of people to test the limits, you know, and uh to kind of recreate certain games that they loved that, you know, I I did this with a Commodore 64 game recently and I only got so far before I got bored of the process to be honest.

01:12:23
But um But a lot of people are doing this and having a lot more fun than I did with it. Um and also creating current IP or recreating current IP. And that's really the I think the the big point here.

01:12:35
Um

Jeff Jarvis
01:12:35
Daniel says that you can't see the web page

Jason Howell
01:12:38
Oh, sorry. I thought I put it on stage, but I did not. There we go.

Jeff Jarvis
01:12:41
There we go.

Jason Howell
01:12:42
Um yeah, so an X user spotted uh in the prompt it said do not build a recreation of a specific existing game even if it is renamed or called original um So yeah, Anthropics Addie Asmani confirmed that they added two sentences to Opus 5. 5 to prevent uh any creation or regeneration or recreation of existing games. So there you go.

01:13:10
Because people are vibecoding all sorts of things and reconstructing certain things. I hope this doesn't happen with the um with the uh the op the uh the the firmware stuff that we were talking about from a couple of weeks ago Because there's some real creative stuff happening there right now. I continue to follow that and it's pretty pretty interesting.

01:13:30
All right, well that is that. I think we've hit the end of the episode. JeffJarvis.

01:13:35
com for everything Jeff is up to, Hot Type, Web We Weave, and all of his other books, Gutenberg Parenthesis, so many, so many.

Jeff Jarvis
01:13:42
Autographed copies sitting there waiting for you at the Montclair Book Center if you follow the link at Jeff Travis. com.

Jason Howell
01:13:47
Yes, the link still works, therefore there is still an aut autographed version of the book.

Jeff Jarvis
01:13:52
I also autographed a cut one copy of Gutenberg Parenthesis there too.

Jason Howell
01:13:57
Oh that's a that's a deep cut.

Jeff Jarvis
01:14:00
Yes.

Jason Howell
01:14:03
Right on. Jeff Jarvis's all new newly redesigned website. Go there, Jeff Jarvis.

Jeff Jarvis
01:14:09
Thank you, Jake Jarvis.

Jason Howell
01:14:11
Yes. Thank you, Jake.

Jeff Jarvis
01:14:12
I don't know how many uh uh tokens he he used to do this, but it's very nice.

Jason Howell
01:14:17
It looks very nice. It's a wonderful website. Uh everything you might need and a little bit more is already there for you.

Jeff Jarvis
01:14:23
Yep.

Jason Howell
01:14:24
Uh podtuneup. com if you want to talk with me about your podcast, um, strategy for building your podcast, strategy for uh you know turning your podcast into a money-making thing. All of these things. Um yeah, I got I actually got a a new client earlier this week and I I just love it because it's so much fun to like talk to people about their podcast. I absolutely love it. So

Jeff Jarvis
01:14:48
it's one of the great things about watching you as a consultant is you really enjoy working with these people.

Jason Howell
01:14:52
Yeah.

Jeff Jarvis
01:14:53
Joy hearing their problems and trying to think them out together and bringing your knowledge to bear. It's fun to watch you do that

Jason Howell
01:14:59
It's helpful for me too because like I've been doing podcasts the way I've been doing it for 20 plus years. It's cool to talk to people and see how they're doing it. And it's illuminating to me because I'm like, oh Oh, I hadn't really thought about that aspect.

01:15:13
So I feel like I'm learning a lot more about the breadth of of the many different ways that you can approach this business of podcasting. And that just gives me more knowledge to share with others. So anyways, podtuneup.

01:15:26
com, hit me up. Uh AIInside. show.

01:15:29
Yes, we do have a new webpage. I'm also very, very happy with this webpage and the way it uh the way it turned out. I will talk about this in a future episode, I promise, but um you're gonna have to wait for that.

01:15:39
Uh AI inside. show for all the information you need about this show. Ways to subscribe.

01:15:45
Everything you need is there. And my uh my voice is is leaving me, so I'll make it quick. Patreon.

01:15:51
com slash AI Inside Show if you want to support us On a deeper level you can. We have some amazing executive producers supporting us very deeply. We appreciate you.

01:16:01
Dr. Do Jeffrey Maricini, Radio Asheville 103. 7, Dante St. James, Bono Derrick, Jason Knifer, Jason Brady, Anthony Downs, Mark Starcher, Karsten Samocchi, and Evan Musiel. Uh we thank each and every one of you.

01:16:16
You don't have to support us at a at the executive producer level, but if you do, you get some bonuses like that. And uh a little bit lower than that, you know, you get your AI inside daily with all of my awkward frozen thumbnails uh of me in the midst of talking and and all that, uh, Discord access, ad-free episodes of this podcast, and so much more Patreon. com slash AI Inside Show.

01:16:38
All right, Jeff, I think that's it. Oh, also I don't want to forget to thank uh Daniel Croft and Anthony Lamos behind the scenes who help us on the video side of things. Could do it without you both.

01:16:49
So thank you. And thank you, Jeff. Appreciate hanging out with you.

01:16:53
And we'll see y'all on another episode of AI Inside. Take care. Bye.